Poles Apart in Climate Response
NOAA-While the Arctic
and the Antarctic experience similar greenhouse gas levels and
solar radiation, each region responds in a dramatically
different way, especially in temperature and loss of sea ice,
says an international team of scientists that includes a NOAA
oceanographer. While the Arctic is warming, most of Antarctica
is not, largely because of the ozone hole, but projections
indicate that is likely to change.
“While some people
would say this is a paradox, these different responses are
mostly consistent with what we know about how the climate
system works,” said James Overland, lead author and an
oceanographer at NOAA’s
Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory in Seattle.
The findings, based on
an October 2007 polar climate workshop, will be published in
the May 6 issue of EOS, a publication of the American
Geophysical Union. Co-authors are John Turner and Gareth
Marshall of the British Antarctic Survey, Jennifer Francis of
Rutgers University, Nathan Gillett of the University of East
Anglia, and Michael Tjernstrom of Stockholm University.
attended the Seattle workshop that looked at the Polar Regions
from 1987 to 2007. The scientists concluded, based on new
research since the 2007 Intergovernmental Panel on Climate
Change Report, that a combination of factors is responsible
for the recent dramatic sea ice loss in the Arctic as well as
masking some of the effects in the Antarctic.
Experienced seasonal temperatures that at times were more
than four degrees Fahrenheit
warmer than usual.
For most of the Antarctic, temperatures were not unusual,
except on the Antarctic Peninsula, a finger of land and
ice about 1,000 miles south of the tip of South America,
which had the largest increase in temperatures of any
location in the Southern Hemisphere. Temperatures warmed
by three degrees Fahrenheit. Warming temperatures and
exposure to ocean waves were cited by the National Snow
and Ice Data Center as the cause of the collapse of a
160-square-mile segment of the Wilkins Ice Shelf on the
Antarctic Peninsula, which began collapsing in late
Summer sea ice loss was greater and declining more rapidly
than climate models projected.
- Antarctic: The
amount and stability of the sea ice was not unusual.
- Arctic: There
are multiple causes for change.
“In the Arctic,
there is a combination of factors, such as warming of the
air because of more greenhouse gases, an unusual wind
pattern, and warming of the ocean water in regions with
reduced sea ice,” said Overland.
- Antarctic: Story
Gillett, a climate
dynamics scientist, said, “In the Antarctic, the changes
in winds and temperatures are consistent with how we would
expect them to respond to increased greenhouse gases and
depletion of stratospheric ozone.”
The depletion of ozone
has strengthened the atmospheric circulation, called the
Southern Annual Mode, or SAM. As the ozone hole recovers,
the winds that currently whiz around Antarctica and block
air masses from crossing into the continent’s interior
would weaken, and Antarctica would no longer be so isolated
from global warming patterns.
Sea ice losses will continue. The study says that a
combination of factors has sent the Arctic into a new
state of sea ice loss, which is occurring much earlier
than projected by climate models subject to greenhouse
warming of the ocean and an overall thinning of the sea ice
makes it difficult for the Arctic to now return to earlier
conditions,” says Overland.
The National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration, an agency of the U.S. Commerce
Department, is dedicated to enhancing economic security and
national safety through the prediction and research of weather
and climate-related events and information service delivery
for transportation, and by providing environmental stewardship
of our nation's coastal and marine resources. Through the
emerging Global Earth Observation System of Systems (GEOSS),
NOAA is working with its federal partners, more than 70
countries and the European Commission to develop a global
monitoring network that is as integrated as the planet it
observes, predicts and protects.
Scientists project that the ozone hole should fully
recover by 2070.
“As the ozone hole recovers, we expect that warming will
appear on the central plateau of Antarctica and we will
see a reduction in sea ice area,” said Turner.